2018 Topps Tier One Baseball Cards

Alot id throw away cards and even the stars dont fetch much. People seem to push back on sets like this. Unfortunately tribute doesnt get you Mich back and that’s a beautiful set. My best pull is a 1/1 limited lumber suto from Ichiro. 5yrs from now when hes 1st Japanese player in Cooperstown, it might fetch something insane. As all expensive sets it has drawbacks, but that 1 banger can make it worth it. I’m a Pirate fan and got a Honus Wagner(and Jeter) legend relic which was also nice.

I feel fortunate that I wasn’t in the ‘dud’ category on this one considering the price for a case – but got an Ohtani redemption that pretty much covered half my buy in along with some other nice silver/10 of Randy Johnson and Gary Sanchez as well. I wish the jerseys were of a better quality than your average 1 per box in topps flagship, but then again you’re really not buying this product for those cards.

For the price point, I’m not at all impressed. Finally caved in and grabbed a box/pack today. Kyle Scwarber Auto, Amir Garrett Auto and a Dominic Smith Relic…..for $140……Not making that mistake again…

agree with sweetleftyswing, the difference between high and low is crazy ridiculous, I got lucky and am happy with my Andy Pettitte auto relic, one of my favorite Yankees! while the base cards are nice and all, it is over priced.

The difference between the high end and the low end in this set is ridiculous. Most of the autographs are the equivalent to Bowman base cards. Overpriced. Nice design though, better than Tribute

Topps ought to be a shamed I finally get a chance to buy an upper tier hobby product and the three cards I got wouldn’t even cover the gas I used going from orange beach to Pensacola to find a damn hobby shop an hour away. Piss poor!

The checklist for all the high end products is so bad now it ruins the fun of breaking. The same players recycled through all the products like usual, just buy what you like based upon design. I’m pretty much certain I won’t buy any more boxes or packs this year as the price is simply outrageous and I don’t want my 19th Ben Gamel, Raimel Tapia, or Matt Duffy auto. At least the design is really nice but no value, no fun, and no money to waste on junk 120$ packs.

Can confirm that the box I purchased just today had 4 cards in. 1/1 auto dual relic a relic and an auto.

Echo the sentiment of above with one minor adjustment to Ron’s comment – 95% of these cards are worthless nostalgia pieces. Watched multiple case breaks online and saw lots of single color patches numbered to 275 and above and autos of players with zero sale value. Foolishly still bought two boxes thinking mine would be different and ended up with autos of greats like Juan Gonzalez and single color patches of Jose Altuve. Never again Topps

Thought this product paid off pretty well. Pulled a Roberto Alomar Limited Lumber 1/1 out of the six boxes I bought.

You only get one pack (3 cards per box)? Seems like a rip off for 3 cards or is that a typo?

Busted a case. The comment about 90% of these autos being worthless is pretty much true. If I was reselling I would lose a huge amount of money. Totally stupid for busting these boxes. Live and learn.

Interesting to see Ken Griffey Jr. autographs in this product. Since he signed with the new company, his autograph signings have been in up in the air. I’m waiting on a autograph redemption of him from 2017 Topps Finest…..

Wow! At least 90 percent of this is complete, utterly worthless, unsalable junk, as usual. And only one Ohtani and one Judge autograph. Pass once again. You have to be nuts to go for this. And millions of you will prove that once again.

Even though Tier One is the ultimate gamble of a product the cards are usually pretty nice and the potential of a monster box is too great to usually pass up. I feel more satisfied opening a box of this than I do opening a box of the more expensive Museum Collection or Tribute especially because the quality of hits tends to be the same just one less than those two products. I am glad that they only included one Ohtani auto in the checklist so it should keep prices in check and honestly there are still really good rookies in this set, even with 1 Ohtani and no Acuña, that tend to be overlooked right now.

While I can’t say I’m overly excited about this product, I think they will be a lot nicer in hand than on screen.

FYI for all who didn’t know, this product was pushed back until May 23rd.

I am excited about the Canseco bat knob and limited lumber cards!

Seriously, where’s the checklist??

Where is the checklist? would like to see who is in this product before preorder.